You are here

Region

Region section

UN, Western envoys urge Tunisia to restore judicial watchdog

By - Feb 08,2022 - Last updated at Feb 08,2022

Members of the Tunisian security forces stand outside the closed headquarters of Tunisia’s Supreme Judicial Council in the capital Tunis on Monday (AFP photo)

TUNIS — Tunisian President Kais Saied faced growing pressure on Tuesday from judges, the UN and world powers after he scrapped a key judicial watchdog, triggering renewed accusations he is moving towards authoritarian rule.

Saied dissolved the Supreme Judicial Council on Sunday, months after sacking the government and seizing wide-reaching powers in the North African country, often lauded as the only democracy to emerge from the 2011 Arab revolts.

The former law professor had long inveighed against the council, accusing members of blocking investigations into the 2013 assassinations of leftist political figures Chokri Belaid and Mohamed Brahmi.

He had also accused his nemesis, the Islamist-inspired Ennahdha Party that had played a central role in Tunisian politics for the decade between the revolution and Saied’s power grab, of infiltrating the body.

The president, who has put fighting corruption at the heart of his programme, insisted on Monday that he would “never interfere with the judiciary” and that removing the judicial council was necessary as Tunisians wanted the country “cleansed”.

But his removal of the council, set up in 2016 to shield judges from government influence, sparked renewed anger from critics who say he is installing a new dictatorship, 11 years after the fall of dictator Zine Al Abidine Ben Ali.

Those fears have been fuelled by the increasing use of military courts to try civilians.

In Tunis, the envoys of the G-7 nations and the European Union said they were “deeply concerned” about Saied’s move against the council, “whose mission is to ensure the sound functioning of the justice system and respect for its independence”.

“A transparent, independent and efficient judiciary and the separation of powers are essential for a functioning democracy that serves its people,” they said.

Amnesty International said Saied’s “attack” on the body was “a grave threat to fair trial rights”.

“If the president enacts a decree to dissolve or suspend the institution, it will sound the death knell for judicial independence in the country,” said the rights group’s Regional Director Heba Morayef.

 

‘Flagrant violation’ 

 

That came hours after Washington — which has often given Saied the benefit of the doubt following similar moves — also voiced its concern, calling an independent judiciary “a core element of an effective and transparent democracy”.

“It is essential that the government of Tunisia holds its commitments to respect the independence of the judiciary, as stipulated in the constitution,” said State Department spokesman Ned Price.

A month after his July 25 power grab, Saied had given himself new powers effectively allowing him to rule by decree and suspending parts of the 2014 constitution — a document he has since vowed to replace.

His latest move gets rid of a body that had been mandated to ensure the functioning of justice, keep the judiciary independent and appoint judges.

On Monday, police blocked access to the council’s headquarters, preventing members and staff from entering.

The body’s president Youssef Bouzakher called the move “illegal”, and on Tuesday the Association of Tunisian Magistrates said it was “a flagrant violation of the separation of powers” that would be ensured in a “democratic regime”.

The association also announced a judges’ strike “at all courts across the country on Wednesday and Thursday” as well as a protest outside the council’s offices on Thursday.

 

‘Stifling dissent’ 

 

Ennahdha said Saied’s decision showed he was “trying to take control of the judicial apparatus to use it to eliminate his political rivals”.

Saied’s move also sparked criticism from the UN in Geneva, where High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet called it “a big step in the wrong direction”.

Dissolving the body “is in clear violation of Tunisia’s obligations under international human rights law”, she said.

She also pointed out that the judicial council’s establishment in 2016 had been seen as a major advance for the rule of law, separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary in Tunisia.

Bachelet also decried online hate campaigns and threats directed at the council’s members, and called for all necessary measures to be taken to ensure their safety.

She said that since July, “there have been increasing attempts to stifle dissent, including through harassment of civil society actors”.

 

Door reopens to candidates after Iraq president vote fails

By - Feb 08,2022 - Last updated at Feb 08,2022

BAGHDAD — Iraq’s parliament announced on Tuesday the reopening of registration for presidential candidates, a day after it called off a session to vote in a new head of state.

One of the two frontrunners, former longtime foreign minister Hoshyar Zebari, was “temporarily” suspended by a court, citing years-old corruption accusations after a complaint was filed against him.

His eligibility for the post is being reviewed, with his party announcing it is sticking with his candidacy and that a verdict is expected within days.

Iraq’s political timeline for electing a head of state and forming a government, in the wake of last year’s general election, has been derailed amid political infighting.

Monday’s voting session was not held due to lack of a quorum after several key political blocs and parties announced boycotts — against the backdrop of competing claims to a parliamentary majority.

The office of parliament speaker Mohamed Al Halbussi announced on Tuesday the “reopening of registration for candidates for the post of president of the republic from Wednesday, February 9 and for a period of three days”.

But a date has yet to be announced for a new voting session in parliament.

Only 58 MPs attended Monday’s session — well below the quorum of two thirds of the 329-seat chamber.

The largest political bloc led by firebrand Shiite cleric Moqtada Sadr, as well as the allied Sovereignty Coalition led by Halbussi and the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) — from which Zebari hails — all announced boycotts ahead of the session.

Legal expert Ali Al Tamimi denounced Tuesday’s announcement as “unconstitutional”, noting that the legal deadline set to elect a president “cannot be broken, except by a decision from the Federal Court or an amendment of the law”.

Zebari was tipped as one of two frontrunners, out of a total of 25, for the presidency. The other is incumbent President Barham Saleh of the KDP’s rival party, the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK).

In response to his suspension, the head of the KDP’s parliamentary bloc, Vyan Sabri, told the state news agency INA on Tuesday: “Mr Zebari is still our sole candidate.”

She denounced the “malicious complaint” leading to his suspension, affirming that his case “will be decided in the next two days”.

Iraq turmoil deepens as presidential vote postponed indefinitely

Parliament seems unlikely to reach quorum

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

This handout photo released by Iraq's Prime Minister's Media Office on Monday shows few Iraqi lawmakers attending a scheduled parliament session in Baghdad, with most major political blocs boycotting it (AFP photo)

BAGHDAD — Iraq's parliament on Monday indefinitely postponed a scheduled vote for the republic's president after most major political blocs boycotted the session.

The sweeping no-show deepens a political crisis in the war-scarred country which, almost four months after a general election, still hasn't chosen a new prime minister.

The assembly vote had been set for noon for the head of state — a post with a four-year mandate held by convention by a member of Iraq's Kurdish minority, and currently occupied by Barham Saleh.

But a series of boycott calls had made it highly unlikely the 329-seat parliament in Baghdad's high-security Green Zone would be able to clinch the necessary two-thirds quorum.

Then, on Monday afternoon, with only a few dozen MPs in the chamber, an official speaking on condition of anonymity confirmed to AFP that "there will be no vote to elect the president".

The turmoil comes after October polls were marred by record-low turnout, post-election threats and violence, and a delay of several months until final results were confirmed.

Intense negotiations among political groups since then have failed to form a majority parliamentary coalition to name a new prime minister to succeed Mustafa Al Kadhemi.

The largest parliamentary bloc to emerge from the vote, led by powerful Shiite Muslim cleric Moqtada Sadr and holding 73 seats, was first to announce a boycott, on Saturday.

It was followed on Sunday by the 51-member Sovereignty Coalition led by a Sadr ally, parliamentary Speaker Mohammed Al Halbussi.

The 31-seat Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) then announced it would also stay away, in order to "continue consultations and dialogue between political blocs".

Another key bloc, the Cooperation Framework grouping several Shiite parties, also said the session should not take place, citing the recent political turmoil.

The process towards a presidential vote had been further thrown into disarray when Iraq's supreme court on Sunday suspended the candidacy of Saleh's key challenger, Hoshyar Zebari, 68.

The court cited corruption charges against Zebari, a former foreign minister from the KDP — allegations he denies.

“I have not been convicted in any court,” Zebari had said in a television interview on Friday as the charges resurfaced alongside forecasts he would unseat Saleh.

Incumbent Saleh, the other frontrunner out of some 25 candidates, represents the KDP’s main rival in Iraqi Kurdistan, the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK).

The supreme court said it was suspending Zebari after receiving a complaint from lawmakers that his candidacy was “unconstitutional” because of the graft claims.

The complainants cited his 2016 dismissal from the post of finance minister by parliament “over charges linked to financial and administrative corruption”.

The complaint also cited at least two other judicial cases linked to him, including when he was Iraq’s long-time foreign minister after the fall of or Saddam Hussein in the 2003 US-led invasion.

 

‘Share the pie’ 

 

Monday’s postponement exacerbates Iraq’s political troubles because it is the task of the president, within 15 days of being elected, to formally name a prime minister from the largest bloc in parliament.

The prime minister, a Shiite Muslim according to political tradition, then has a month to form his government.

Sadr’s bloc claims it controls enough seats for a “national majority government”.

However, the Coordination Framework has appealed to the Supreme Court to have their grouping recognised as the biggest.

The country’s apex court has rejected this demand, saying it could not decide now, as the size of parliamentary blocs could shift.

In Iraqi politics, said analyst Hamzeh Hadad, “everyone knows how to share the pie” but “no one knows how to be in the opposition”.

First UAE National Council delegation visits Israeli parliament

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

OCCUPIED JERUSALEM — Three members of the United Arab Emirates' Federal National Council visited Israel's parliament on Monday, becoming the first Emirati delegation there since the US-brokered normalisation of ties in 2020.

"When we talk about Abraham Accords agreements, we want you to look at the big picture," Ali Rashid Al Nuaimi, chairman of the council's defence, interior and foreign affairs committee, said at the Israeli foreign and defence committee.

"It's not a political agreement only, it's not an issue related to security and defence issue. No, it is an agent of change for the whole region," Nuaimi said, advocating "full engagement in all sectors".

Prior to the visit to the Knesset, the Emirati delegation visited Yad Vashem, Israel’s Holocaust memorial.

one.

Nuaimi said that after the 2021 war between Israel and Hamas, the Islamist rulers of Gaza, “people were questioning what will happen to the Abraham Accords”, the name of the agreements brokered under the Donald Trump administration

“I want everyone to know there is no way back, we are moving forward, we are not repeating history, we are writing history,” he said.

Ram Ben Barak, head of the Israeli foreign and defence committee hosting Nuaimi as well as fellow Federal National Council members Sara Falaknaz and Marwan Almheiri, called his guests “neighbours and brothers”.

“There’s a misconception, as though the normalisation agreement was based on just one element, of shared threats and challenges, but that’s the smallest part of the deal,” he said.

“Israel is committed to the agreement and plans on enhancing and expanding it in all fields.”

Bahrain and Morocco have also normalised ties with Israel under the accords. Sudan has agreed to do so, but formal diplomatic relations have not yet emerged amid escalating instability in Khartoum.

Tunisia police blockade dissolved judicial watchdog

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

TUNIS — Tunisian police on Monday blocked access to the country's top judicial watchdog in a move its chief slammed as "illegal", two days after President Kais Saied dissolved the body.

Security forces blocked all roads to the Supreme Judicial Council (CSM) headquarters in Tunis.

"We don't know who issued these orders but we know that they have no legal basis," CSM president Youssef Bouzakher told AFP.

Saied dissolved the body on Sunday, months after sacking the government and seizing wide-reaching powers in Tunisia, often lauded as the only democracy to emerge from the 2011 Arab revolts.

His supporters say his power grab on July 25 was necessary after a decade of misgovernance by corrupt political parties.

Saied vowed on Monday that he would not interfere in court cases or judicial appointments.

"I will never interfere with the judiciary," he said, adding that he had only taken the CSM decision "because it had become necessary, and because the Tunisian people want the country to be cleansed".

Speaking to Prime Minister Najla Bouden in a filmed meeting posted on his Facebook page, he said the courts had been the scene of "farces".

"Whoever thought the judiciary was a tool to achieve his own personal or political goals must know that he will never be able to infiltrate the courts."

But critics say Saied has pushed the country down a dangerous route back towards autocracy.

Bouzakher said the closure of the CSM “proves that we have entered a phase where the executive is using force to seize control of all state institutions, including the judiciary”.

Warning of threats to “rights and liberties”, he said the CSM would carry on with its work.

Saied had said Sunday that the CSM was corrupt and had delayed politically sensitive investigations into the assassinations of left-wing opposition figures Chokri Belaid and Mohamed Brahmi.

The CSM said he lacked the legal and constitutional authority to dissolve it.

The body, created in 2016, consists of 45 magistrates, mainly appointed by parliament, and has the power to appoint judges.

Rights groups plead for Yemen rebels to free journalists

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

DUBAI — Media rights groups on Monday urged Yemen's Houthi rebels to free four journalists sentenced to death for "espionage" in the war-torn country.

The four, Abdul Khaleq Amran, Tawfiq al-Mansouri, Harith Hamid, and Akram Al Walidi were arrested in June 2015 in Yemen's rebel-held capital Sanaa.

The Iran-backed Houthis seized Sanaa from the internationally recognised government in 2014, sparking a civil war that has devastated the already impoverished country.

In April 2020, a Houthi court sentenced the four journalists to death on charges of "treason and spying for foreign states", a verdict condemned at the time by Yemen's government.

"Their arrest was motivated by their reporting on human rights violations committed by Houthi forces," the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) and the Yemeni Journalists' Syndicate (YJS) said in a joint statement.

The two organisations said they were "launching an emergency call... to put pressure on the Houthi authorities to release our colleagues and save their lives".

The Brussels-based IFJ, which represents journalists and unions from more than 140 countries, said the four had suffered “physical and psychological torture” as well as the “denial of the right to be visited and the right to have access to medical care”.

At the time of their trial, Amnesty International criticised their sentencing on “trumped-up charges”, while Reporters Without Borders called the verdict “totally unacceptable”.

Hundreds of thousands have been killed and millions displaced in Yemen’s conflict, which the United Nations has labelled the world’s worst humanitarian crisis.

Lebanese museum returns millennia-old antiquities to Iraq

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

Laith Majid Hussein (left), head of Iraq's Antiquities Authority, and Iraqi deputy foreign minister, Ahmed Tahseen Barwari, pose for a photo with boxes containing more than 300 ancient artifacts returned by Lebanon during a press conference at Baghdad airport, on Monday (AFP photo)

BAGHDAD — More than 300 ancient cuneiform writing tablets were returned to Iraq on Monday from a private Lebanese museum, as part of Baghdad's widespread efforts to restore antiquities looted during years of war.

Sealed wooden boxes transported the 331 tablets bearing ancient cuneiform script from the Nabu Museum in northern Lebanon to Baghdad, an AFP journalist said.

Iraq has seen its historical artifacts looted for decades, including since the invasion by the United States in 2003, and the rise of the Islamic State militant group 10 years later.

"Today, Iraq has restored 331 cuneiform tablets," the director of the Iraqi council of antiquities and heritage, Laith Majid Hussein, told reporters.

The tablets date back to different eras, he added, ranging from the Akkadian empire starting in 2,400BC, to the third Sumerian dynasty of Ur and through to the ancient Babylonian empire, ending in 1,594BC.

The kingdom of Ur, founded more than 4,500 years ago, was one of the first centres of civilisation.

Built on the banks of the Euphrates River, it was the site of the first examples of writing in cuneiform script.

Hussein thanked Lebanon for their cooperation, as well as the director of the Nabu Museum for having "facilitated the restoration".

On Sunday, an official Iraqi delegation received the artefacts in a ceremony at the National Museum of Beirut.

The Nabu Museum, named after the Mesopotamian god of wisdom and writing, opened its doors in 2018 with a collection of antiquities — some more than 3,000 years old — originating in Lebanon, Iraq, Syria, Egypt and Yemen.

The returned pieces came from private collections, most notably that of Jawad Adra, husband of former Lebanese defence minister Zeina Akar.

His private collection includes some 2,000 pieces, according to the museum catalogue.

Iraq has recovered more than 18,000 artefacts in one year, the vast majority of them from the United States.

In December, the Iraqi authorities held a ceremony to celebrate the return of the prized Gilgamesh tablet, dating back more than 3,500 years.

Morocco buries little Rayan who died trapped in well

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

Moroccans carry the body of five-year-old Rayan Oram during his funeral in the village of Ighrane in Morocco’s rural northern province of Chefchaouen, on Monday (AFP photo)

GHRANE, Morocco — Moroccans on Monday attended the funeral of Rayan, a five-year-old boy who spent five days trapped down a well, sparking a vast rescue operation that gripped the world but ended in tragedy.

The boy had fallen down a narrow, 32 metre dry well last Tuesday, sparking a complex earth-moving operation to try to reach him without triggering a landslide.

Well-wishers had flooded social media with messages of sympathy and prayers that he would be brought out alive, but their hopes were dashed.

On Saturday night, crowds had cheered as rescue workers cleared away the final handfuls of soil to reach him, after the marathon digging operation in the village of Ighrane in northern Morocco’s impoverished Rif mountains.

But the joy turned to grief when the Royal Cabinet of the North African nation announced that the boy was dead.

King Mohammed VI called the parents to voice his condolences.

The child’s body was taken to a military hospital in the capital Rabat, accompanied by his parents.

On Monday it was transported to the Douar Zaouia cemetary near his village, where hundreds of mourners attended his funeral, AFP journalists said.

Nation in shock 

 

Rayan’s father Khaled Aourram said he had been repairing the well when his son fell in, close to the family home.

The shaft, just 45 centimetres across, was too narrow for Rayan to be reached directly, and widening it was deemed too risky — so earth movers dug a wide slope into the hill.

Rescue crews, using bulldozers and front-end loaders, excavated the surrounding red earth down to the level where the boy was trapped, before drill teams carefully dug a horizontal tunnel to reach him from the side to avoid causing a landslide.

Vast crowds came to offer their support, singing and praying to encourage the rescuers who worked around the clock.

But the boy’s death left Moroccans in shock.

Mourad Fazoui in Rabat mourned what he said was a disaster. “May his soul rest in peace and may God open the gates of heaven to him,” the salesman said.

The Arabic daily newspaper Assabah criticised the digging of unauthorised wells, saying many were used to irrigate cannabis widely grown in Morocco’s north.

Social media across the Arab world were flooded with messages of support, grief, and praise for rescue workers.

“He has brought people together around him,” one Twitter user said.

But one deplored a “dystopian world” where “Arab nations are moved” by the Morocco rescue operation for the child while vast numbers of infants die in conflict or famine in Yemen and Syria.

 

Libyan parliament interviews prime minister candidates

By - Feb 07,2022 - Last updated at Feb 07,2022

BENGHAZI, Libya — Libya’s parliament on Monday began hearings of hopefuls to replace interim Prime Minister Abdulhamid Dbeibah, a process that could spark new east-west power struggles in the troubled North African nation.

Dbeibah’s government took power a year ago with a mandate to lead Libya to December elections aimed at dragging the country out of a decade of conflict.

But since the polls were indefinitely postponed amid deep divisions over their legal basis and controversial presidential candidates, parliament speaker Aguila Saleh has led efforts to have Dbeibah replaced.

Both eastern-based Saleh and Dbeibah, in the western capital Tripoli, were presidential candidates.

Dbeibah has said he will only hand power to an elected administration.

Saleh’s House of Representatives, based in eastern Libya since a violent schism in 2014, said two out of seven candidates had made it through to the final round.

Powerful former interior minister Fathi Bashagha, 59, and outsider Khaled Al Bibass, 51, a former official in the interior ministry, will face a parliamentary vote on Thursday.

Bashagha told the assembly that he wanted to unify divided state institutions, improve security and revive the country’s dismal public services. He also vowed not to stand for future elections.

Bibass said he would work to overcome the country’s divisions and fight inflation.

Libya has seen a decade of conflict since the 2011 revolt that toppled dictator Muammar Qadhafi, leaving a patchwork of militias vying for control over an oil-rich country riven by deep tribal and regional divisions.

Thursday’s vote could see a repeat of a 2014 schism which saw two parallel governments emerge.

The parliament also adopted a “roadmap” towards elections, which looks set to delay the polls further.

It says they must take place within 14 months of an agreement on another divisive issue — a new constitutional declaration.

Qadhafi scrapped Libya’s last constitution when he seized power in 1969.

The assembly is not fully united, and some members have called for Dbeibah to stay in office until elections are held.

The United Nations has also called for a new date to be set for presidential polls rather than yet another transitional government.

 

Iraq presidential vote in question after boycotts, court ruling

By - Feb 06,2022 - Last updated at Feb 06,2022

BAGHDAD — Doubts hung on Sunday over a scheduled parliamentary vote for Iraq’s president after the supreme court temporarily suspended former foreign minister Hoshyar Zebari, a frontrunner for the post, and leading parliamentary factions announced a boycott.

The decisions not to attend Monday’s session again highlight political divisions in a war-scarred country hobbled by corruption and poverty.

The largest parliamentary bloc, holding 73 seats and led by powerful Shiite cleric Moqtada Sadr, was the first to boycott, saying on Saturday it would not attend the session which is scheduled for midday (09:00 GMT).

That was followed on Sunday with a boycott by the Sovereignty Coalition, made up of 51 MPs and led by parliamentary speaker and Sadr ally Mohammed Al Halbussi.

The third party in their informal alliance, the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP), from which Zebari hails, said it, too, would not be there to fill its 31 seats. This is in order to “continue consultations and dialogue between political blocs”, it said.

Their decision came after the supreme court cited years-old corruption charges against Zebari in suspending him.

The successive boycotts could result in Monday’s session being cancelled or postponed due to lack of a quorum, which is set at two thirds of the 329-seat chamber.

A scheduled presidential vote follows October legislative elections marred by record-low turnout, post-election threats and violence, and a delay until final results were confirmed in late December.

Intense negotiations among political groups since then have failed to form a majority parliamentary coalition to name a prime minister.

 

‘Unconstitutional’ 

 

Zebari was one of two main contenders for the largely ceremonial post of president, which has a four-year mandate and by convention is held by a member of Iraq’s Kurdish minority.

The other favoured candidate, out of roughly 25 in total, is the incumbent Barham Saleh. He is the candidate of KDP’s rival in Iraqi Kurdistan, the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK).

In suspending Zebari, the court said it had received a complaint from lawmakers that his candidacy was “unconstitutional” because of the graft claims.

It said the suspension was “temporary” while the court considers the case.

Iraq’s highest judicial body said the complainants consider that Zebari does not fulfil constitutional requirements that the head of state must have “a good reputation and integrity”.

The court cited his 2016 dismissal from the post of finance minister by parliament “over charges linked to financial and administrative corruption”.

Public funds worth $1.8 million were allegedly diverted to pay for airline tickets for his personal security detail.

Zebari, 68, has always denied all corruption accusations.

“I have not been convicted in any court,” Zebari said in a television interview on Friday night as the charges resurfaced alongside forecasts he would unseat Saleh.

The complaint also cited at least two other judicial cases linked to him, including when he was the country’s long-time foreign minister after the fall of Saddam Hussein in the 2003 US-led invasion.

 

‘Not a consensus’ candidate 

 

“Our withdrawal is a message to the Kurds, in particular to the KDP, for them to agree on a single candidate,” a Sadrist MP told AFP, speaking on condition of anonymity due to the sensitivity of the issue.

The MP, whose bloc’s leader Sadr controls the complex negotiations to select a new prime minister, said Zebari was “not a consensus” candidate.

But while Sadr’s bloc claims it has enough seats for a “national majority government”, the powerful rival Shiite Coordination Framework, appealed to the supreme court to have their bloc recognised as the majority.

The court rejected their demand, saying it could not decide now, as parliamentary blocs could change.

“No one knows how to be in the opposition. Everyone knows how to share the pie,” Iraqi political analyst Hamzeh Hadad said

 

Pages

Pages



Newsletter

Get top stories and blog posts emailed to you each day.

PDF