Mom and dad often catch hospital errors doctors missed

Parents often catch medical errors that their child’s doctor missed, according to a US study that suggests families may be an untapped resource for improving hospital safety and preventing mistakes. 

Roughly one in ten parents spotted mistakes that physicians did not, according to the study of safety incidents observed on two paediatric units at a hospital in Boston. 

“Parents may notice different things than healthcare providers do, and thereby provide complementary information that can only help make care safer,” said lead study author Dr Alisa Khan, a paediatrics researcher at Harvard Medical School and Boston Children’s Hospital. 

“As anyone who has ever been hospitalised knows, hospitals are very complex places where there are a lot of moving parts, and errors are bound to happen despite all of our best efforts,” Khan added by e-mail. “I think we — including parents — can all work together to keep children safe.”

To assess how frequently parents detect mistakes that doctors didn’t catch, Khan and colleagues reviewed data on 383 kids hospitalised in 2013 and 2014. 

Parents completed written surveys detailing any safety incidents their children experienced during their hospital stays. 

Then, two physician reviewers classified incidents as medical errors, other quality issues, or situations that weren’t safety problems. 

Overall, 34 parents (8.9 per cent) reported 37 safety incidents, the researchers report in JAMA Paediatrics.

When doctors reviewed these incidents, they found 62 per cent, or 23 of the cases, were medical mistakes. Another 24 per cent, or 9 situations, involved other quality issues. 

The remaining 14 per cent, or 5 cases, were neither mistakes nor quality problems, the physician reviewers concluded. 

For the subset of cases that were medical mistakes, the reviewers found 30 per cent of the incidents caused harm and were preventable. 

Children with medical errors appeared to have longer hospital stays, and these kids were more likely than others in the study to have either metabolic or neuromuscular conditions. 

Preventable errors described by parents included delays detecting a foreign body left behind after a procedure, recognition and treatment of urinary retention, and receipt of pain medication. 

In one case a poorly dressed wound got contaminated with stool, while in another instance a child got an infection from an unused intravenous catheter. 

Parents identified communication problems as a contributing factor in a number of errors, including instances when day and night staff didn’t note a medication change and when written information for one patient was documented in a different patient’s medical record. 

Beyond its small size and the fact that it was conducted at just one hospital, other limitations of the study include its reliance on English-speaking parents and its sample of participants who were predominantly female, well-educated and affluent, the authors note. 

Kids of non-English-speaking parents may be particularly vulnerable to errors, and it’s possible that including these families might have exposed even higher rates of parent-reported errors, the researchers point out. 

Even so, the findings add to a growing body of evidence suggesting that clinicians may often be unaware of errors affecting their patients, said Dr Daniel Neuspiel, a paediatric researcher at the University of North Carolina School of Medicine in Charlotte who wasn’t involved in the study. 

“The specific frequency of such errors may differ in other populations, but we know they occur in all clinical settings,” Neuspiel added by email. 

While the study is too small to draw broad conclusions on error rates or safety, it still highlights the value of parents speaking up when something seems amiss with their child’s care, said Dr. Irini Kolaitis, a paediatric researcher at Northwestern Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago who wasn’t involved in the study. 

“A parent knows their child better than any member of the healthcare team does, stands by their bedside and plays an active role in their child’s healthcare delivery throughout their hospitalisation and after discharge, and often has a sense when something is not right,” Kolaitis said by e-mail. “For these reasons, any perceived error that a parent reports, noting in the care of their child must be taken seriously.”